Meet Us At The Market.
Fresh-baked cookies, five bold flavors, and a little taste of New York. Come find NYC Anthers at the market and discover your new favorite cookie.
A cookie made
for New York.
I'm a lifelong New Yorker, and I've tasted more black and white cookies than I can count over the years. Most were disappointing — plastic-tasting, one-note lemony, or just... bland. I could never find one that lived up to what I knew it could be.
The inspiration to make something great started with my dad. He grew up in The Bronx in the 1940s, in an observant Jewish family, and he's the one who taught me about our Ashkenazi Jewish heritage — including the story, often told, that Ashkenazi Jewish bakers helped bring the black and white cookie to New York City in the early 1900s. He passed away a few years ago. When I decided to start this business, I thought this would be a meaningful way to honor his memory.
A real taste of New York, made to be worthy of iconic status.
THE FLAVORS OF NYCPick Your Favorites.
Small-batch cookies baked fresh for the weekend. Choose your flavors, build your box, and select where you'll pick it up.
Fresh From Our Oven.
BEST SELLER
The Original
Vanilla cake, half dipped in dark chocolate fondant, half in vanilla. The argument starter.
RICH & FUDGY
Red Velvet Divide
Cocoa-red cake on one side, cream cheese fondant on the other. Loud and proud.
HOUSE FAVORITE
Cinnamon Babka
Swirled cinnamon-sugar cake, half glazed dark, half left golden. A Brooklyn bakery favorite.
SWEET + SALTY
Pistachio Park
Toasted pistachio cake split between deep olive and pale green fondant. Quietly the boldest one.
NEW
Lemon Borough
Bright lemon cake, half in citrus glaze, half in vanilla. Built for a hot sidewalk.
Our cookies are baked in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, peanuts and tree nuts. Please contact us if you have specific allergy concerns before ordering.
Taste
New York.
Five boroughs. Five distinct personalities. Two ways to bring the whole city home. Drag to explore.
Brooklyn
Guittard L'Étoile du Nord 64% Chocolaté & Real Madagascar Vanilla
The original. Classic, bold, and iconic — just like the borough that started it all. Its two flavors as timeless as the bridge that bears its name.
↗
Manhattan
Fresh Lemon Juice and Zest, with Real Madagascar Vanilla
Bright, bold, and a little electric — just like the city that never sleeps. Sharp lemon meets smooth vanilla, just as Manhattan's energy meets its elegance.
↗
The Bronx
Slow-Simmered Raspberry Jam & Real Madagascar Vanilla
Bold and full of heart, with a burst of tart raspberry — the Bronx doesn't do subtle, and neither does this cookie.
↗
Queens
Roasted Peanut Butter & Guittard L'Étoile du Nord 64% Chocolate
Home to more languages and cultures than anywhere on Earth — outstanding flavors, even better together.
↗
Staten Island
Artisanal Pistachio Cream & Guittard L'Étoile du Nord 64% Chocolaté
The green borough. Unexpected, a little underrated, and quietly extraordinary. Lush pistachio grounded in dark chocolate.
↗
Five Borough
Bag of Cookies
Why chose! Get one of each borough, with an extra bite of Brooklyn.
↗
The City
Box of Cookies
Bring home the whole city! Three each of The Bronx and Queens, two each of Brooklyn, Manhattan, and Staten Island.
↗Get the good stuff.
Be the first to hear about new cookie drops, launch updates, special batches, and everything happening behind the scenes at NYC ANTHERS.
A little NYC in your inbox.
Join our email list and be part of the NYC ANTHERS community.
Meet us in DUMBO.
NYC ANTHERS makes its location debut at the Brooklyn Flea in DUMBO. Come find us under the iconic DUMBO Arch and taste what we're bringing to Brooklyn.
Questions,
Answered.
Everything you need to know about ordering, pickup, storage and enjoying your cookies.
Choose your cookies from the Shop page, select your quantity and choose the market where you'd like to pick up your order.
Pre-orders close [DAY] at [TIME] for the upcoming market.
Orders placed after the deadline may not be available for that week's market. Check our latest market announcement for availability.
Orders are picked up at our booth during the selected market's operating hours. Your selected pickup location will be shown with your order details.
Please contact us as soon as possible. We cannot guarantee availability outside the designated pickup window.
Keep cookies in an airtight container at room temperature and enjoy within [X] days for best quality.
Yes. Place cookies in an airtight, freezer-safe container or bag. Allow them to thaw before serving.
Warm the cookie briefly before serving. Exact heating time will depend on your cookie size and appliance.
Pre-orders may be cancelled or modified up to 48 hours before the selected market.
Orders cancelled less than 48 hours before market day may not be eligible for a refund because ingredients and baking preparations may already have been completed.
If you are unable to collect your order during the selected market's pickup hours, please contact us as soon as possible.
Because our cookies are freshly prepared for each market, unclaimed orders may not be available for later pickup or refund.
Let's Talk
Cookies.
Have a question, planning an event, or interested in a larger order? We'd love to hear from you.
Find the split.
Two shops, same argument. Find your favorite NYC ANTHERS spot and come get your cookies.